ProtonVPN
vs
Private Internet Access

ProtonVPN vs Private Internet Access

ProtonVPN and Private Internet Access (PIA) are both known for transparency, but one leans on privacy ideals and the other on proven legal resilience. ProtonVPN has Swiss engineering and uncompromising privacy…

ProtonVPN

Best for: Privacy-focused
  • No-logs Policy
  • Multi-Hop
  • Independent Audits

ProtonVPN is a Swiss VPN from the Proton Mail team with open-source apps and a free tier that has no data cap or ads. It suits privacy-first users.

£3.59/month
End of year sale: 75% off

Private Internet Access

Best for: Advanced users
  • No-logs Policy
  • Simultaneous Connections
  • Open Source Apps

Private Internet Access is a US-based VPN that had no user logs to hand over in three court cases. Deloitte audited it in 2025. Suits budget power users.

£2.99/month

Detailed Comparison

ProtonVPN and Private Internet Access (PIA) are both known for transparency, but one leans on privacy ideals and the other on proven legal resilience. ProtonVPN has Swiss engineering and uncompromising privacy principles. PIA has a legendary reputation, earned through court-tested transparency and technical excellence.

PIA has the stronger legal record. Its no-logs policy has been tested in court multiple times. Each time, its claims were shown to be true. ProtonVPN is based in privacy-friendly Switzerland but hasn't faced the same legal scrutiny. PIA gives you granular control over encryption, protocols and connection settings, while ProtonVPN concentrates on user-friendly privacy built to Swiss engineering standards.

PIA runs over 35,000 servers, while ProtonVPN's network is smaller and focused on quality. ProtonVPN is well ahead on free use with unlimited bandwidth (speed-limited), while PIA has no free tier. For privacy features, ProtonVPN has Secure Core routing and Swiss jurisdiction, while PIA has its proven, court-tested transparency.

The apps differ a lot. ProtonVPN's are more intuitive, with a privacy-focused design. PIA's technical depth can overwhelm casual users.

Key Metrics

Rating
ProtonVPN
4/5
vs
Private Internet Access
4.1/5
Monthly Price
ProtonVPN
£3.59
vs
Private Internet Access
£2.99

Feature Comparison

FeatureProtonVPNPrivate Internet Access
Ad & Tracker Blocking
Anonymous Payment Methods
Connection Protocols
Custom VPN Protocols
Customer Support Availability
Dedicated IP Option
Encryption Standard
Independent Audits
IPv6 Leak Protection
Kill Switch
Multi-Hop
No-logs Policy
Open Source Apps
RAM-only Servers
Simultaneous Connections
Split Tunneling
Streaming Support
Support Channels
Torrenting Support

Our Verdict

Your technical skill and privacy priorities decide the winner. Choose ProtonVPN for Swiss privacy laws, user-friendly apps and a strong free tier if you'd rather have principled privacy than technical complexity. Select PIA if you're technically inclined and value court-tested transparency, maximum customization and proven legal resilience. For mainstream privacy advocates, ProtonVPN is easier to use. For technical users, PIA gives more control.

Related Content

Related Articles

Related Content

Recommended VPN

Surfshark

Best for: Affordability
  • Simultaneous Connections
  • Ad & Tracker Blocking
  • Multi-Hop

Surfshark is a lower-priced VPN with unlimited device connections and a no-logs policy verified twice by Deloitte. It suits households with many devices.

£2.49/month
3 months extra free

CyberGhost

Best for: Streaming and gaming
  • Simultaneous Connections
  • Streaming Support
  • Ad & Tracker Blocking

CyberGhost is a Romania-based VPN with servers sorted by task, such as streaming or torrenting. It suits streaming households who want a simple app.

£10.89/month