Mullvad
vs
Private Internet Access

Mullvad vs Private Internet Access

Mullvad and Private Internet Access (PIA) both have strong records on transparency but earn trust differently. Mullvad is a privacy cooperative built on complete anonymity. PIA is well known for court-tested…

Mullvad

Best for: Anonymous payments
  • No-logs Policy
  • Independent Audits
  • Anonymous Payment Methods

Swedish VPN that signs you up with a random account number and charges a flat 5 euros a month. Suits privacy-first users who can live without streaming.

£4.29/month

Private Internet Access

Best for: Advanced users
  • No-logs Policy
  • Simultaneous Connections
  • Open Source Apps

Private Internet Access is a US-based VPN that had no user logs to hand over in three court cases. Deloitte audited it in 2025. Suits budget power users.

£2.99/month

Detailed Comparison

Mullvad and Private Internet Access (PIA) both have strong records on transparency but earn trust differently. Mullvad is a privacy cooperative built on complete anonymity. PIA is well known for court-tested transparency and technical depth.

PIA has court-tested proof of its no-logs policy from multiple legal victories. Mullvad offers complete operational transparency and anonymous account management. Mullvad accepts anonymous cash payments and assigns random account numbers, while PIA uses conventional payment systems.

PIA gives you granular control over encryption, protocols and connection settings. Mullvad concentrates on the WireGuard protocol and strong technical engineering. PIA runs over 35,000 servers. Mullvad's network is smaller and focused on quality.

Mullvad charges exactly €5/month to everyone. PIA's prices vary, with significant discounts on long-term plans. Both expect some technical knowledge, though PIA offers more customization and Mullvad is cleaner and simpler.

Both are excellent on privacy, by different routes. PIA has proven legal resilience. Mullvad has complete anonymity and transparency.

Key Metrics

Rating
Mullvad
4/5
vs
Private Internet Access
4.1/5
Monthly Price
Mullvad
£4.29
vs
Private Internet Access
£2.99

Feature Comparison

FeatureMullvadPrivate Internet Access
Ad & Tracker Blocking
Anonymous Payment Methods
Connection Protocols
Custom VPN Protocols
Customer Support Availability
Dedicated IP Option
Encryption Standard
Independent Audits
IPv6 Leak Protection
Kill Switch
Multi-Hop
No-logs Policy
Open Source Apps
RAM-only Servers
Simultaneous Connections
Split Tunneling
Streaming Support
Support Channels
Torrenting Support

Our Verdict

The choice depends on which kind of transparency you trust and how much technical control you want. Choose Mullvad if complete anonymity comes first and you value full operational transparency, anonymous payments and a simple, ethical service. Choose PIA if you're technically inclined, want maximum customization and value transparency that has been tested and proven in court. If complete anonymity is your priority, Mullvad offers as much privacy as any provider. Technical users who want proven transparency get stronger legal validation from PIA.

Related Content

Related Articles

Related Content

Recommended VPN

Surfshark

Best for: Affordability
  • Simultaneous Connections
  • Ad & Tracker Blocking
  • Multi-Hop

Surfshark is a lower-priced VPN with unlimited device connections and a no-logs policy verified twice by Deloitte. It suits households with many devices.

£2.49/month
3 months extra free

ProtonVPN

Best for: Privacy-focused
  • No-logs Policy
  • Multi-Hop
  • Independent Audits

ProtonVPN is a Swiss VPN from the Proton Mail team with open-source apps and a free tier that has no data cap or ads. It suits privacy-first users.

£3.59/month
End of year sale: 75% off