VPN for Chrome: Browser Extension vs App, Which Is Enough
PCMag rates a full VPN app above a Chrome extension for most readers, leaving the extension to streaming, locked-down computers and PCs that aren't yours. Surfshark costs the least of the four on our site at £2.19 a month on its 12-month plan, so it is my pick for the app.
| Provider | Price a month, 12-month plan | Devices at once | Ad and tracker blocking | Open-source apps |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Surfshark | £2.19 | Unlimited | Yes | No |
| ProtonVPN | £2.39 | 10 | Yes | Yes |
| ExpressVPN | £3.99 | 10 | Yes | No |
| NordVPN | £4.09 | 10 | No | Yes |
Our own comparison data at The VPN Advisor, last checked in November 2026, puts NordVPN's latency to a nearby server at 14 ms and ExpressVPN's at 31 ms.
Chrome VPN extensions differ in what they run
Chrome has no VPN extension built in, so every one you add comes from a third party, sorted by PCMag into lightweight VPN, proxy and remote-control types. A lightweight VPN extension acts as a split tunnel for Chrome alone, with other traffic left on your regular connection.
A proxy extension may skip encryption altogether, leaving what you browse in plain view of your internet provider. A remote-control extension runs no VPN itself. It connects to the main app installed on your computer and drives it from the browser.
Extensions protect the browser only
NordVPN's extension sets up faster than its app. Surfshark's extension also covers browser traffic alone, leaving the rest of your device on its regular IP address. Windscribe tells its users that connecting in the extension alone reroutes only browser traffic, so every other program goes out on your personal IP. Its desktop app runs a full tunnel for everything on the computer, against a lightweight browser proxy in the extension.
PureVPN names what that leaves out, since apps like Discord, Zoom and Spotify sit outside a browser extension's reach. PCMag notes that a VPN installed on the computer encrypts all of its outgoing traffic, at the price of slower downloads and uploads and higher latency. On Proton's premium servers, PCMag measured downloads falling 20.11% and uploads 43.21%, with latency up 351.26%.
Browser leaks an extension can still block
ExpressVPN says a WebRTC leak can expose your real IP even with its app running, because the leak happens inside the browser. ExpressVPN's extension stops WebRTC requests and fakes your HTML5 location. Its Ad Blocker and Threat Manager need an Advanced or Pro subscription. NordVPN's extension blocks WebRTC leaks and ads, and lets you pick sites that skip the encrypted connection. PureVPN adds that some extensions also spoof GPS and offer a bypass proxy for chosen sites.
Surfshark's CleanWeb runs on its extension too, blocking ads and pop-ups and warning you about data breaches and malware in Chrome, Firefox and Edge. Incognito mode reduces cookie and fingerprint tracking, by ExpressVPN's account, yet leaves your IP address showing to your internet provider. Google can still follow what you do on its own services if you're signed in, VPN or no VPN.
Full apps keep the strongest features
Proton VPN's extension lacks part of what its app offers, by PCMag's count, though it still encrypts over HTTPS and carries DoubleVPN inside the browser. Its free tier has no data limit. NordVPN keeps Double VPN, obfuscated servers and app-level split tunneling for its app. ExpressVPN's Internet Kill Switch belongs to the app too, beyond the extension's reach.
NordVPN's extension has a kill switch that cuts the browser off if the VPN drops. ExpressVPN's extension lets you choose its Lightway and Lightway Turbo protocols, a choice ExpressVPN says most Chrome extensions don't give.
Running an extension beside its app
On ExpressVPN, the Chrome extension acts as a remote for the desktop app, which must be installed first. Paired that way, it becomes a dashboard for encryption across the whole device.
NordVPN advises against running its app and extension together, since each interferes with the other's connection. Surfshark gives the same warning unless you exclude the browser with its Bypasser feature. Windscribe treats the pairing as a feature, sending your traffic through two locations in Double Hop mode when both are connected.
An extension alone fits a few uses
NordVPN's extension has a pause button that switches protection off for a set time and reconnects by itself afterward. Windscribe suggests its extension for ad and tracker blocking and its desktop app for the VPN tunnel itself. Its extension can also change your user agent, spoof the time and clear cookies once a tab closes.
Surfshark's listing says mobile Chrome can't run extensions, so Android and iOS users need its standalone app. PCMag also warns that malicious extensions occasionally get past Google's approval system. It recommends installing one only from a trusted link on the VPN's own website. A VPN can't stop every threat either, so PCMag pairs one with antivirus, a password manager and multi-factor authentication.
Surfshark's app for most, NordVPN's extension for a locked PC
Install Surfshark as a full app if you want everything on your computer covered, because its apps cut your traffic off if the VPN connection drops. Its support pages don't list a kill switch for the browser extension, so keep the app for that protection.
Choose NordVPN when you can only add an extension, at work or on a borrowed PC, because its proxy extension needs no admin rights. A year of it costs £22.80 more than Surfshark, as our NordVPN vs Surfshark comparison shows.
ExpressVPN serves someone who already runs its desktop app better, since adding the extension to that app still counts as one device connection.



